The Illusion of Youth
I have struggled with my weight for my entire adult life, which, given my age, covers a heck of a lot of territory. About 2 years ago I went on one of those pre-packaged food plans. Your typical low calorie, low fat, high carb, low protein kinda thing. I lost 59 pounds in 17 months.
The problem was the last 6 months I was on the diet I only lost 8 pounds and I was CONSTANTLY hungry. I did NOT cheat. I followed the plan, kept my calories within the 1200-1300 range. I grew so fatigued I couldn’t even do my workouts.
I finally decided to take a break.
This coincided with my discovery of a book by Gary Taubes entitled Good Calories, Bad Calories which had been mentioned in one of hubby’s newsletters. As I read I realized that poor, vilified Dr. Atkins had been right all along. Thus began my low carb journey.
Four months into it I still haven’t lost any weight. As a matter of fact, when I quit the low fat low calorie regimen I gained (and I fully expected it to happen) 12 pounds. First I panicked. Then I got angry. Then I tried to rationalize. Then I discovered my daily body temp averages (AVERAGES mind you, some days it’s actually LOWER) 96.5° a full TWO DEGREES below normal.
I begged my doctor to check my thyroid. Tests showed well within normal ranges. He said my temperature was fine. I cajoled. He capitulated and gave me 4 weeks worth of thyroid. Less than a week into taking them I developed the shakes so tossed the remainder in the trash.
I sought advice from folks on the various low carb forums. One in particular has been extremely helpful. Yes. My metabolism slowed waaaaay down to compensate for the long term low calorie intake. Eat a minimum of 1700 calories per day getting at least 65% from fat and keeping the carbs at about 20g per day. I chowed down on steak, burgers, butter, cream, mayo, all the wonderful stuff “they” keep telling us is bad for us. And I have not gained another pound.
I continued reading. Ultimately had to buy my own copy of Taubes’s book because the library wanted theirs back. found references to a couple of more interesting sounding books and got them in. Now I’m questioning the whole “obese” thing.
I’m currenty reading Paul Campos’s The Diet Myth and within the first 30 pages find myself so incensed I think every single agency within the government that has been touting low fat, the-sky-is-falling-because-the-entire-country-is-obese should be disbanded immediately, their offices torched and the ashes sown with salt.
But I’m getting off track.
One of the things Campos said that really has resonated with me is that the whole diet industry (and make no mistake, it’s a HUGE one and mostly responsible for this madness) is slyly suggesting that by staying slim we will stay young and pert.
Holy cow. That idea has been percolating in the back of my mind the last several weeks. I’d been thinking that when we’re teens we are naturally rail thin. When I was 14 I weighed a dainty 130 pounds and I was, in the words of lecherous uncle, all legs. I was probably about a size 10, the closest I have ever been to single digit sizes in my life. The following year I bounced up to 145 and was in a size 12. I wound up the next year about 165 and I went back and forth between 142 and 165 for about 15 years. At 32 I started gaining and it didn’t stop until I did the diet thing.
In looking back I realize that the only way I stayed around 140 was to basically starve myself. At one point I was madly measuring calories and was thrilled to discover that by eating about 750 calories a day I got my weight back down to 135. holy crap.
I look at the actresses who are all underweight and how if they even approach a normal weight are then pilloried as FAT by the media.
The two thoughts collided and I realized (before reading Campos) that it’s a YOUTH thing. By staying rail thin one can pretend they are still teens.
sick. sick sick sick sick.
Campos also talks about how BMI and wight tables came about. It was someone in the insurance industry trying to figure out some way to measure mortality rates. It has NOTHING to do with health or even with what one should or should not weigh.
Well I’m not that far into the book yet but it’s good reading so far. Because of what I’ve read I’ve readjusted where I think my weight should be … up from 140 (which was my stated goal with the diet company) to a more sane and probably healthier 165. Turns out the older you are, as in over 60, the better it is to have a little extra meat on your bones.
Pass the steak.



